A request for arbitration and a statement of claim are both documents used in the arbitration process, but they serve different purposes and are used at different stages:
Request for Arbitration
Role in the Arbitration Process:
The request for arbitration is the formal initiation of the arbitration process. It is the document that informs the opposing party and the relevant arbitral institution (if applicable) that the claimant wishes to resolve a dispute through arbitration.
It triggers procedural steps such as the appointment of arbitrators, the setting of timelines, and the organization of preliminary meetings or conferences.
Content:
Identification of the Parties:
This section identifies the parties involved in the dispute, typically including their names, addresses, and contact information.
Reference to the Arbitration Agreement:
The request often cites the specific arbitration clause or agreement that governs the dispute. This is crucial because it establishes the legal basis for referring the matter to arbitration rather than court litigation.
Summary of the Dispute:
While brief, this section outlines the nature of the dispute, giving a general overview of the issues at hand.
Relief Sought:
The claimant will generally indicate the type of relief or remedy they are seeking, such as monetary compensation, specific performance, or declaratory relief.
Procedural Information:
Depending on the arbitration rules being followed, the request might include suggestions or preferences for the number of arbitrators, the language of the arbitration, the seat (location) of the arbitration, and any preferred procedural rules.
Timing and Importance of the Request for Arbitration:
The request for arbitration is the first step in the arbitration process. Once submitted, it usually leads to the constitution of the arbitral tribunal.
Its importance lies in its ability to set the stage for the entire arbitration process, including influencing procedural decisions and the timeline.
Statement of Claim:
Role in the Arbitration Process:
The statement of claim is a detailed, substantive document that forms the cornerstone of the claimant’s case. It is submitted after the arbitral tribunal is constituted and typically follows any preliminary procedural orders.
This document is critical because it provides the arbitrators with the full scope of the claimant’s case, laying out both the factual narrative and the legal basis for the claims.
Content:
Detailed Facts:
The statement of claim offers a comprehensive and chronological account of the facts leading to the dispute. This section often includes a narrative of events, supported by evidence such as contracts, correspondence, and other relevant documents.
Legal Grounds:
This section outlines the legal theories and arguments supporting the claimant’s case. It might reference specific laws, legal precedents, or interpretations of the contract under dispute.
Relief Sought:
Here, the claimant specifies the exact relief they are seeking, which could be in the form of damages, injunctions, specific performance, or declaratory relief. This section is much more detailed than in the request for arbitration.
Supporting Evidence:
The statement of claim will usually include or reference documentary evidence, witness statements, and expert reports that support the claimant’s arguments.
Legal Arguments:
Finally, the claimant will provide a detailed analysis of how the facts and evidence support their legal claims, making the case for why the arbitral tribunal should rule in their favor.
Timing and Importance of the Request for Arbitraiton and the Statement of Claim:
The statement of claim is typically submitted after the tribunal is constituted and any preliminary issues are resolved. It marks the beginning of the substantive phase of the arbitration, where the focus shifts from procedural matters to the merits of the dispute.
Its importance lies in its role as the primary document upon which the claimant’s case is built. It is also critical for setting the agenda for the rest of the arbitration, including the responses from the opposing party, the framing of issues, and the direction of hearings and evidence gathering.
Key Differences between a Request for Arbitration and the Statement of Claim:
- Timing: The request for arbitration is the initiating document, while the statement of claim is submitted later, once the arbitration process is fully underway.
- Detail: The request for arbitration is relatively brief and procedural, while the statement of claim is detailed and substantive, providing the full argumentation and evidence.
- Purpose: The request for arbitration serves to start the process and establish the framework, whereas the statement of claim aims to persuade the tribunal of the merits of the claimant’s case.
Understanding these distinctions is crucial for navigating the arbitration process effectively, ensuring that each document serves its intended purpose at the right stage of the proceedings.
***
We trust that the above is of assistance when considering to start an arbitration. Expert advice is recommended at an early stage of the dispute to evaluate the best procedural route.
For more information about UAE law you can visit all our publications in this link as well as the videos of our director Maria Rubert.
**This publication is not intended as legal advice and rather as general information.