info@rubertpartners.com |
+971 4 528 0625 |
API World Tower - Ground Floor, Dubai
Introduction
In international arbitration, factual witnesses play a critical role in providing firsthand accounts of the events surrounding a dispute. Unlike expert witnesses, who provide specialized knowledge and opinions on technical matters, factual witnesses contribute by recounting their personal experiences or involvement with the case. Their testimonies help the tribunal gain a clearer understanding of the facts, which is essential for a fair resolution.
Importance of Factual Witnesses
Factual witnesses serve as the backbone of the evidentiary process in arbitration. Their testimony is often pivotal in clarifying ambiguities, especially in disputes involving complex commercial relationships, cross-border transactions, or long-term contracts. By offering detailed accounts of negotiations, events, or decisions, factual witnesses bridge the gap between the written record and the actual circumstances in which disputes arise.
In international arbitration, where parties and arbitrators may come from diverse legal and cultural backgrounds, the role of factual witnesses becomes even more significant. Their testimony can shed light on industry practices, commercial customs, and local business norms that may be unfamiliar to the tribunal.
Preparing Factual Witnesses
The credibility and effectiveness of a factual witness often depend on thorough preparation. This includes reviewing relevant documents, understanding the legal issues in the dispute, and, most importantly, avoiding embellishments or inconsistencies. A well-prepared witness should focus on presenting facts rather than interpretations or opinions. In international arbitration, where the arbitral tribunal has wide discretion in assessing evidence, inconsistencies or signs of coaching can diminish the weight of a witness’s testimony.
Furthermore, factual witnesses must be able to communicate effectively in arbitration proceedings, which are often conducted in English or another language that may not be the witness’s native language. Legal teams must consider translation needs and the potential impact of language barriers on a witness’s ability to present their evidence clearly and persuasively.
Challenges with Factual Witness Testimony
Despite their importance, the use of factual witnesses in international arbitration can raise challenges. For one, their testimony may be influenced by the party presenting them, leading to concerns about partiality. This risk is heightened in international disputes where the witnesses are often closely tied to one of the parties, such as company employees or former directors. Tribunals are typically aware of this and exercise caution in weighing witness testimony against other forms of evidence, such as contemporaneous documents.
Another challenge is the variability in legal systems concerning the role of factual witnesses. Some jurisdictions rely heavily on oral testimony, while others place more emphasis on documentary evidence. This can lead to differences in how factual witness testimony is treated or valued, depending on the tribunal’s legal background.
Additionally, cultural differences can play a significant role in the presentation and perception of witness testimony. In certain cultures, witnesses may be less comfortable expressing themselves assertively or contradicting authority, while in others, witnesses may be more inclined to embellish or dramatize events. Tribunals must remain sensitive to these nuances when assessing the reliability and credibility of factual witnesses.
Written Witness Statements and Cross-Examination
In international arbitration, factual witnesses often submit written witness statements before the hearing. These statements outline their version of the facts and form the basis for their oral testimony at the hearing. The witness statement is a crucial document that allows the tribunal and the opposing party to prepare for the hearing, particularly for the cross-examination stage.
Cross-examination provides an opportunity for the opposing party to challenge the credibility and reliability of a factual witness. Effective cross-examination can expose inconsistencies, biases, or gaps in the witness’s account. However, overly aggressive cross-examination techniques can backfire, especially if they appear to bully or discredit a sincere witness.
The Tribunal’s Approach to Factual Witnesses
Arbitral tribunals have significant discretion in evaluating the weight of factual witness testimony. They typically assess the credibility, consistency, and plausibility of the witness’s account, as well as the coherence with documentary evidence. In complex international disputes, tribunals often face the challenge of reconciling conflicting witness testimony, and their decision may hinge on which version of events they find most credible.
Tribunals also consider the context in which the testimony is given. For instance, they may weigh the potential bias of witnesses who are employed by or have a close relationship with one of the parties. Additionally, they may take into account the inherent limitations of human memory, particularly when the events in question occurred several years before the arbitration.
Conclusion
Factual witnesses are a cornerstone of the evidentiary process in international arbitration. While their testimony is indispensable for establishing the facts of a dispute, it must be weighed carefully in light of potential biases, inconsistencies, and cultural differences. The effective use of factual witnesses requires thoughtful preparation and an awareness of the challenges that come with presenting oral evidence in a multicultural and multilingual context.
As international arbitration continues to evolve, the role of factual witnesses will remain a key element in ensuring that disputes are resolved based on a comprehensive and accurate understanding of the facts.
***
We hope this post will help you understand the role of factual witnesses in international arbitration and remain available for any questions regarding this post of general application.
For more information published in English you can visit all our publications at this link as well as the videos in English of our Managing Partner Maria Rubert.
*The information on this page is not intended to be legal advice.